BAS Observatory Insights

Explore how Parties engage with IPCC evidence, best available science and wider scientific evidence. Build comparisons using country categories, Annex classifications and assessment results. Select any pivot cell to see the Parties behind the result.

Counting rule: European Union member states are represented once through the European Union Party. LDC, SIDS and EIT are overlapping country categories.

↓ Jump to Interactive Pivot Table & Tool

Country Categorisations and IPCC Engagement

Of the 126 State Parties included in this reviewed analysis, 16 appear as Annex I and 11 as Annex II Parties under the UNFCCC. 3 of the submitted NDCs come from Annex I Parties designated as economies in transition (EIT). The remaining 110 NDCs were submitted by Non-Annex I Parties. Within the Non-Annex I category, we established sub-categories for Least Developed Countries (LDCs) and Small Island Developing States (SIDS): 23 NDCs were submitted exclusively by LDCs, 25 exclusively by SIDS, and 4 by Parties that are classed as both an LDC and a SIDS.

Country Category Substantial Partial Minimal No mention Total
Annex I
11(68.8%)
3(18.8%)
2(12.5%)
0(0.0%)
16
Annex II
9(81.8%)
2(18.2%)
0(0.0%)
0(0.0%)
11
Non-Annex I
19(17.3%)
73(66.4%)
12(10.9%)
6(5.5%)
110
Sub-Categories
EIT
0(0.0%)
1(33.3%)
2(66.7%)
0(0.0%)
3
LDCs
2(8.7%)
17(73.9%)
2(8.7%)
2(8.7%)
23
SIDS
2(8.0%)
21(84.0%)
1(4.0%)
1(4.0%)
25
SIDS & LDC
1(25.0%)
1(25.0%)
2(50.0%)
0(0.0%)
4
Table 1: Country Category vs. IPCC Engagement (party counts and row percentages)

With regard to IPCC engagement, of those NDCs submitted by State Parties contained in Annex I, 68.8% engaged substantially with the IPCC, 18.8% engaged partially, and 12.5% engaged minimally. For State Parties in Annex II, 81.8% engaged substantially with the IPCC in the articulation of the NDC, and a further 18.2% engaged partially, meaning no State Parties in this category engaged minimally or omitted the IPCC.

Of those countries classed as Non-Annex I, 17.3% substantially engaged with the IPCC, with a further 66.4% articulating partial engagement. 10.9% exhibited minimal engagement, and the final 5.5% made no mention.

Of Non-Annex I countries categorised as LDCs, 8.7% engage substantially with the IPCC, while 73.9% have partially engaged. 8.7% have minimal engagement, and 8.7% do not mention the IPCC. For SIDS, 8.0% engage substantially, while 84.0% engage partially, 4.0% minimally, and 4.0% fail to mention it altogether. Of the countries that are both SIDS and LDCs, 25.0% engage substantially, 25.0% partially, and 50.0% minimally.

References to Best Available Science (BAS)

With regard to best available science, 7 of the 16 Annex I Parties referenced best available science and 9 did not. 7 of the 11 countries that appear in Annex II referenced best available science. Of all Non-Annex I countries (inclusive of sub-categories), a total of 25 reference best available science. Within the 25 Non-Annex I NDCs that contain such references, 4 were submitted by LDCs, 5 by SIDS, and 1 by a Party classed as both an LDC and a SIDS.

Country Category Yes No Total
Annex I
7(43.8%)
9(56.2%)
16
Annex II
7(63.6%)
4(36.4%)
11
Non-Annex I
25(22.7%)
85(77.3%)
110
Sub-Categories
EIT
0(0.0%)
3(100.0%)
3
LDCs
4(17.4%)
19(82.6%)
23
SIDS
5(20.0%)
20(80.0%)
25
SIDS & LDC
1(25.0%)
3(75.0%)
4
Table 2: Does the Country Reference Best Available Science? (party counts and percentages)

In terms of percentages, 43.8% of Annex I and 63.6% of Annex II countries reference best available science. All Annex I countries that refer to BAS also appear in Annex II, meaning none of the EIT NDCs contained references to BAS. Of State Parties categorised as Non-Annex I, 22.7% referenced BAS. Amongst SIDS, the percentage was 20.0%, and for LDCs, this was 17.4%. 25.0% of State Parties categorised as both SIDS and LDCs made reference to best available science.

Our categorisation revealed that amongst State Parties categorised as Annex I that also appear in Annex II, the vast majority (>80%) engaged substantially with the IPCC, and this group was the most likely to reference best available science (>60%). In contrast, none of the Annex I Economies in Transition (EIT) exhibited substantial IPCC engagement or referenced BAS. Across Non-Annex I countries, the majority of NDCs articulated partial IPCC engagement and did not make reference to best available science.

Technical Annex: Country Categorisations

Having examined how references to the IPCC are articulated by State Parties in their NDCs and the extent to which references are made to science and the concept of best available science, we sought to identify patterns, correlations, and commonalities between states that engage with science to a greater or lesser degree. In order to do this, we divided State Parties into primary categories and sub-categories:

Primary Categories

  • Annex I: Parties listed in Annex I of the UNFCCC, comprising industrialised countries. These Parties have specific commitments under the Convention, including adopting national policies and measures to mitigate climate change, limiting greenhouse gas emissions, and reporting regularly on emissions and implementation progress.
  • Annex II: A subset of Annex I Parties consisting of OECD member countries listed in Annex II of the UNFCCC. In addition to fulfilling Annex I mitigation and reporting commitments, these Parties are required to provide financial resources, facilitate the transfer of environmentally sound technologies, and support adaptation and capacity-building efforts in developing country Parties.
  • Non-Annex I: Parties not included in Annex I of the UNFCCC. This category comprises predominantly developing countries and does not carry the specific mitigation, reporting, and financial obligations assigned to Annex I and Annex II Parties under Article 4 of the Convention.

Sub-Categories

  • Economies in Transition (EIT): Annex I Parties with economies in transition, primarily countries transitioning from centrally planned to market economies. These Parties are subject to Annex I mitigation and reporting commitments but, unlike other Annex I countries, do not feature in Annex II.
  • Least Developed Countries (LDCs): Non-Annex I Parties that are designated by the United Nations as Least Developed Countries. These countries are recognised as having the lowest levels of socioeconomic development and limited capacity to respond to climate change, and are afforded special consideration under the UNFCCC.
  • Small Island Developing States (SIDS): Non-Annex I Parties that are recognized by the United Nations as Small Island Developing States. They are widely recognized as being particularly vulnerable to the adverse effects of climate change, especially sea-level rise and extreme weather events.
  • Least Developed Country & Small Island Developing States (LDC & SIDS): Non-Annex I Parties recognized by the United Nations as both Least Developed Countries and Small Island Developing States. This subgroup captures countries that share the characteristics and vulnerabilities associated with both UN classifications.

In determining how to divide State Parties, we aligned with those categorisations established by the UNFCCC in 1992 where State Parties are divided into Annex I or Annex II countries with differentiated commitments set out in Article 4. Annex I includes “the developed country Parties” and economies in transition (EIT) and their commitments are outlined in Article 4.2. They include adopting national policies and measures to mitigate climate change and aim to return emissions to earlier levels and to report regularly on implementation.

Annex II contains many of the same State Parties as Annex I; however, those in Annex II countries have additional commitments and must provide developing countries with financial resources to assist in implementing the Convention, help meet adaptation costs, and promote the transfer of environmentally sound technologies and know-how to other Parties. In our analysis, the number of submitted NDCs that are categorised as Annex I is 16 (one of which is the EU, accounting collectively for 27 member states). Of these, 11 are also categorised as Annex II countries.

All remaining 110 countries that form part of our analysis fall within the category of Non-Annex I. Whilst the Convention does not contain a formal annex titled “Non-Annex I” it does refer to “Parties not listed in Annex-I” and this has subsequently been understood to mean Non-Annex I countries. Given that the list of countries falling within the category of Non-Annex I is substantially larger than the list of Annex I countries, we further divided this list to identify subgroups (LDCs, SIDS, and LDC & SIDS) to capture information relating to those NDCs coming from Parties that are widely recognised under the UNFCCC and wider UN system as amongst the most vulnerable to the adverse effects of climate change.

Reviewed Parties0Distinct Parties after EU consolidation
Reviewed NDCs0%
Substantial IPCC engagement0%
Best available science: Yes0%
Science mentioned: Yes0%

Categories overlap, so category totals should not be added together.

How counts and percentages are calculated

Each cell shows a count, the applicable denominator and a percentage. The denominator follows the selected display mode: row total, column total or all included Parties. Annex classifications and country categories are treated as overlapping tags. A Party may therefore appear in more than one row or column, and category totals should not be added together.